Should Murtagh make it to Outlander season 4? A debate
Before we even get to some of those (there’s be plenty of time for discussion there), we have another key question at present and it’s related to Murtagh. While there have definitely been many changes from the source material it’s been the past week or two that has drawn the ire of some fans, but it seems as though keeping this character (played by Duncan Lacroix) alive is one of the book changes most people seem to be getting behind — and for good reason. He’s such a dynamic character and Lacroix plays him with so much passion — he’s also a nice bit of connective tissue to the earlier days of the show. While there are other characters such as Jenny and Ian still around from the first couple of seasons, they weren’t out in the throws of adventure like Jamie and Claire were. Murtagh has a unique perspective and a unique relationship with both Jamie and Claire.
So what could be done with Murtagh moving forward? One possibility is that there is a new storyline carved out for him, whether it be this season or the next, that either fills a narrative void or is a substitute for introducing a new character who there wouldn’t be much time to develop. This is something that we’ve seen Game of Thrones do in the past and it could work here. Obviously some book purists may not like it, but we’re one for mostly sticking to the spirit of the source material since sometimes you do need to take liberties to make it work in the established format.
Obviously, Murtagh was kept alive for a reason — we don’t think that this reason has been 100% fulfilled as of yet.
The issue of course with any question of Murtagh’s future at present is just that so many years have passed since we last saw him. We’d like to assume (for the reason we just mentioned) that he is still alive — yet, is he the same man? Could he already be in America? Does he hold strong feelings for Jamie and Claire anymore? One of the things that is somewhat exciting about the character is that he is one of the first true Outlander mysteries that we have — the show isn’t anywhere close to getting ahead of the Diana Gabaldon source material, so his path forward is one of the few things that both readers and non-readers alike can speculate on.
Should we see Murtagh on Outlander season 4?
Let us know one way or another below! Meanwhile, check out this link to preview more of what is coming Sunday night, or like us on Facebook to get even more insight related to the show. (Photo: Starz.)
Cassandra
November 20, 2017 @ 5:48 am
I’m not a purist. I only just binged through the first 2 seasons this September (on the couch recovering). My first reaction? Seasons 1 & 2 were fantastic & definitely worthy of more Emmy nominations than they got. I’ve had a hard time with season 3, though. And I’ve come to the conclusion that the Murtagh-less landscape is the reason. I’m just not that into the romance, despite the great acting and costumes and production design. Murtagh gave the show grit and touch of realism, which is a testament to the work of the actor behind him. His characterization actually reminds me of older men in my life–part honorable & loyal so that you feel some subconscious attachment to them, part intractable & crotchety so that they make you laugh your a** off, and part surprisingly violent so that you’re never quite sure what they’ll do next. If the producers don’t keep Murtagh in season 4, then they need to write a whole other show for him. (I actually think that keeping him alive was a smart business decision. They’re reaching for a larger audience than just the book fans, and with so many people on the internet saying Murtagh is their favorite character….)
monique rose
November 8, 2017 @ 10:55 pm
Decidedly, KEEP HIM!!! He is one of the Ardsmuir men, after all!
Susanna Åkesson
November 7, 2017 @ 10:36 am
I believe like jdlar53 that he’ll take the place of “Duncan Innes”.
But Duncan is already in the colonies, he was sent with the prisoners from Ardsmuir.
becky
November 5, 2017 @ 6:11 pm
It would be great to see him again at some point..
I haven’t read the books so I have no conflict here. ;)
Laura Moody
November 5, 2017 @ 6:44 am
I’d really like to see his character at least see Claire again.
Shirley Miller
November 5, 2017 @ 4:28 am
I have feared that Murtagh would be the character hanged in the beginning of book four. Hayes I think his name was. It would bring Claire and Jamie together to grieve a shared friend from their past. But we would be as torn up to see a dear friend die so senselessly. I feel that the foundation for the loss of his arm was hinted at with the rat bites on Murtaugh arm as well.
aussiesuzie
November 5, 2017 @ 4:25 am
Well I’m a book purist,but I so loved Duncan L., interpretation of Murtagh,he has done a great job.well Murtagh was at Ardsmuir already & it looked they shipped him of with the other Scot’s as an indenture person,so he is alive!What the powers of adaptation will give him,we’ll see in season 4.It’ll make J&C lives easier as He is the only one who knows about the time travel!
Lorraine M Brown
November 5, 2017 @ 4:14 am
yes! He can’t be left out!
kmc
November 5, 2017 @ 2:32 am
Yes! Everybody needs a Murtagh – especially the fans for season 4 and beyond!
Matt Carter
November 5, 2017 @ 6:20 am
“everybody needs a Murtagh” should be on a t-shirt somewhere!
katerina
November 5, 2017 @ 1:48 am
pPLEASE ….keep him IN ……love his character…..such a good presence ….
biff
November 5, 2017 @ 1:02 am
Why bother to change the material and keep him alive if we aren’t going to see him again.
jdlar53
November 5, 2017 @ 1:02 am
Murtagh could take on the charactor of,”Duncan
Inns”; In the book Duncan goes with
Jamie and Claire to the Colonies to help find Ian who was taken by the pirates.
monique rose
November 8, 2017 @ 10:59 pm
Yes, then he could marry Ellen’s sister!
Claire Oelrichs
November 4, 2017 @ 11:29 pm
Mr Rough Diamond M has to still be in the Jamie not quite family – family team. He is everyones uncle especially Fergus. He kens the time travel. they could find him as a sailor on the ship? Could find him working on a plantation (unlikely), He has definite pirate potential!