‘Game of Thrones’ season 4, episode 5 review: Jon Snow vs. Craster’s Keep; Honor’s move
“Game of Thrones” Sunday night presented an episode that was definitely all across the board when it comes to stories. There were moments in King’s Landing, moments with the Night’s Watch, and also moments all the way out in the Eyrie.
But was this truly a good episode, or just one that tried to do a lot of different things, and didn’t do any of them very well? Our overall take is that “First of His Name” was a solid hour, but not one that was particularly eventful compared to some of the others. There was a lot going on, but most of it was designed to get from point A to point B … save for most of the stuff with Jon Snow at the end.
Jon’s big battle was one that led to the complete destruction of Craster’s Keep, which is probably a good thing given that this place didn’t have much of a legacy. When you are known first and foremost as a place where babies are carted off to the White Walkers, this is not the sort of reputation that you probably are interested in having around for too much longer.
Meanwhile, MASSIVE kudos tonight go to Hodor, who with the help of Bran Stark, did one of the most awesome things possible in keeping himself, Meera, and Jojen Reed all alive.
King’s Landing – Tommen was crowned as the new king, and the commiserating is already beginning to have Margaery become queen again, and then to have Cersei eventually be paired up once again with Loras. Save for a scene then between Cersei and Oberyn, where Cersei’s daughter was discussed heavily, this was a light episode with no Tyrion.
Pod and Brienne – It was inconsequential to see Pod and Brienne out on the road together right now, but it was really funny since Pod does not know how to do really anything except with prostitutes. We’re still happy that this little diversion was here.
Arya – Just in case you forgot, Arya wants to kill a lot of people! Also, The Hound is on there. This guy’s got a big set of balls to continue along his question to the Eyrie even with this threat.
The Eyrie – Speaking of which, is this really a better place for Sansa Stark? She has to deal with all sorts of jealousy when it comes to her late mother … and then, there is also the fact that she wants Sansa to marry her creepy son. Oh, and Littlefinger was genuinely nice this week! He must be up to something, right? Well, we suppose something more than being the conductor behind almost everything we’ve seen. The reveal of him being the mastermind behind almost everything that set in motion his present position needed to be either fleshed-out more, or placed at a part of the episode where there was more punch.
All in all, this was “First of His Name.” Outside of the cool battle (which was Jon Snow and few other people we care about), this was one of the slower episodes of the show. Here’s to hoping for a pickup, and more Tyrion, very soon. Grade: B-.
What did you think about this episode? Share your thoughts below.
GoTFan
May 5, 2014 @ 6:40 pm
I don’t understand the reviews today of last night’s episode.. It feels like I watched a different episode than everyone else – based upon what I have read…in my opinion last night’s episode was HUGE..GAME CHANGING!!!!
It contained the biggest reveal of the entire series thus far — everything we have seen or thought up until this point was a lie! Petyr Baelish is responsible for every single event that took place since the freaking Pilot Episode! For me, that still hasn’t completely sunk in after watching last nights episode..I am in total shock from that 1 little scene ..and have been very confused that other people haven’t given it more weight in their reviews and critiques today! I have to admit that I have not read the books (yet!) I am planning to start them from the beginning after the end of this season ….so I was thinking maybe that in the books this didn’t happen, and the whole Baelish /Lysa Arryn thing was made up for the HBO version of the story?? That is the only explanation I can come up with for the fact that more people aren’t shocked, or discussing that pivotal scene last night!! If you are a reader of the books – please let me know whether or not this is a part of them, because as an avid fan, I would really love to know.
Xenon
May 8, 2014 @ 8:45 am
It happens in the books, so no need to be hyper about it!
The Rover
May 5, 2014 @ 6:11 pm
A B+/B-? Come on, it was one of the most entertaining episodes of GoT since the pilot! Things are moving on and every character’s getting a great chance to shine and stand out. One major revelation (about the true nature of Jon Arryn’s death), one major fight sequence with both Jon Snow & Brandon Stark kicking ass, all paired characters getting good, entertaining scenes (Margaery-Cersei, Cersei-Tywin Lannister, Podrick-Brienne, Cersei-Prince Obryn, Arya-Sandor Clegane, Sansa-Lady Lysa Arryn, Lysa-Littlefinger). Not a single dull moment, some brilliant acting and setting the ‘scene’ for a post-Joffrey Westeros. Its like being in a middle of a brilliant chess game. As Gandalf said – The board is set, the pieces are moving. Exciting times for GoT fans. I found it very satisfying and at the same time, hungry for the next episode.
Xenon
May 5, 2014 @ 4:09 am
Hodor Hodor Hodor! i was literally screaming that, loved the episode.
Maclaren is a great director! :D
leeann
May 5, 2014 @ 12:59 pm
I was screaming for Bran to warg into Hodor and he did not disappoint.
peaceout
May 5, 2014 @ 3:14 am
I thought this episode was great! Sansa finally getting to a family member only to learn just how crazy that member is; and the unexpected role of Littlefinger in John Arryon’s death – all very momentous, and very well done.
leeann
May 5, 2014 @ 12:58 pm
I think Sansa now realizes being married to Tyrion wasn’t so bad. Being married to Lyssa’s son on the other hand? Did you see the look on her face? Poor kid. Her aunt is as crazy as Joffrey.
skippysandberg
May 5, 2014 @ 2:11 am
A necessary episode because mid way through the season, a ton of plot gaps have to be filled in considering what’s coming before the end of this book. So, I give it a better grade than a B-. I give it a B+ because it moved the plot forward, filled in the gaps, and kept us entertained.