‘Hell on Wheels’ season 4, episode 7 review: Did Elam Ferguson survive standoff with Cullen?
It had been two weeks since we’d really seen life in the town of Cheyenne on “Hell on Wheels,” and Saturday night’s episode actually felt somewhat like the eighth episode of “The Walking Dead” season 4. Basically, you had the storylines from two separate episodes colliding, and this led to one of the biggest confrontations and moments of the entire season.
We were extremely worried for Elam Ferguson’s life in this episode, and for good reason. Heck, this episode was even entitled “Elam Ferguson,” which could have been a tribute to him in a way. 45 minutes into the hour, and it wasn’t looking good for him. His mind couldn’t shake that he was the “bear killer,” and he refused to accept the possibility of anything otherwise. He shunned Eva, threatened to kill multiple women, and was not at all fazed by the sight of Cullen Bohannon.
The choreography of this fight scene was extraordinary, as the two men went back and forth, trading blows. It was clear that Cullen did not want to kill Elam; he loved the guy like a brother. Unfortunately, he found himself in a position where he had no choice. This will be a controversial stance to some, but what else could the man do? If Cullen didn’t kill him, the men on the rooftops would have.
The one argument that you could make is that this is a battle Cullen did not have to fight at all. In making this decision to take matters into his own hands, despite his good intentions, he did not think of the possibility of his child growing up without a father. This is who this man is, for better or for worse.
Performance-wise, we have to give the utmost credit to Anson Mount for what may even top his episode 2 performance as his greatest yet of the entire season. The site of him sobbing over Elam’s coffin, juxtaposed against the stillness and the silence of the scenery, is a haunting moment that will stick with us.
So where does this leave Cullen in the end? Before the episode started, we had the character looking to find a way to get out of town with Naomi, and this included taking out a loan to make it happen. Smart move, given John Campbell’s presence and Durant willing to kill some of his men for revenge against his own beating. As for whether or not he will really want to considering moving forward with the railroad or Naomi, we have to wait for the dust to settle.
Perhaps for Elam, maybe it is best to remember him not for these two episodes as the bear-killer, but the character who loved Eva, was a passionate friend, and would have done anything to find Cullen at the end of season 3. Tonight, we watched Cullen do just about the same, and he came up with nothing other than tears and nightmares. Grade: A.
What did you think about tonight’s “Hell on Wheels” episode? Share now in the comments.
hgf
September 15, 2014 @ 6:24 am
I did like the character before but loathed this episode – took me two attempts to get through it.
So curious turned to so disappointed – twice! :(
Joyce Bryant
September 14, 2014 @ 5:45 pm
I thought last night’s episode was well acted, well written, and in keeping with the life in those times. Cullen’s grief over having to kill his friend was palatable. I saw no other recourse for Cullen, nor for the Producers of HoW who had an actor who needed to leave the show. Wish Common well and long may Hell On Wheels continue as one of the best shows on television. Maybe one day it will be finally recognized by the Emmy Awards.
Anne Hunt
September 14, 2014 @ 5:04 pm
Did I seem to any of you that as Elam was holding the knife to Cullen’s forehead he was remembering who Cullen was. Otherwise he should have just driven the knife in. However the shooting scene can be seen two ways. 1) Elam was wondering why his friend had shot him. 2) Elam was begging to be put out of his misery. 3) Or even could Elam have been wondering or remembering at that moment who he was and that he wasn’t impervious to death. – What did Elam’s face say to you?
Owenwinter
September 15, 2014 @ 3:35 am
I’d go with the last one. Elam was broken and finished as a functional person. It would have been cheesy and unrealistic to suddenly have him remember who he was.
The only other outcomes that would have been believable are if Cullen either stepped back to be with his family and let Campbell take Elam out or if Elam had never returned in the first place and we were always left to wonder.
Ronna Cee
September 14, 2014 @ 5:45 am
i wonder why they had to kill him off in such a humiliating and offensive way. i don’t think i can continue with this..
Anne Hunt
September 14, 2014 @ 4:39 pm
I’m sure the reply from Cullen about killing Elam will be, “He was suffering, and I just couldn’t let him go on like that. I loved him too Eva.” Common did an Emmy winning performance but he was such a huge part of this show and now, It has lost it’s likeability. Elam brought a sense of calm to the whole madness of the wild west. If the writers and prducers have any sense they’ll use the week to go back into production with Elam or pull out the scene of him moaning in that damned box.
james
September 14, 2014 @ 4:37 am
Common wanted to leave. He’s dead. Great two episode spurt. Was not expecting this outcome.
Anne Hunt
September 14, 2014 @ 10:18 pm
You know what, I doubt there’s a producer in ffilmdom who isn’t aware of replacing an actor. Even in an established role an actor can be replaced. So why was it that the part of Elam couldn’t be recast?
PanzerV
September 14, 2014 @ 3:47 am
He has bear magic and can’t be terminated…..when Cullen stops bluberring like some kinda yankee pinko, i spect there will be a knock on the instead of the box with a wounded elam sayin let me out of here…..he gets patched up , regains his senses, and keeps makin money as an regular cast member…If a grizzly coudln’t kill em than nether a knife or gunshot can.
Wes Hardin
September 14, 2014 @ 3:11 am
Cullen survives a wolf…however Elam survives a bear and the writers make him deformed and crazy and then kill him….no more for me, you just lost a fan.
HoW fan
September 14, 2014 @ 11:52 am
He asked to leave the show to work in his music career
Wes Hardin
September 14, 2014 @ 4:32 pm
It was not why but how…they killed him like a rabid dog in front of the whole town…I have no more comment on this.
Anne Hunt
September 14, 2014 @ 4:32 pm
So then Common is telling us he isn’t capable of multitasking??? I was about to leave the show weeks ago feeling Common wasn’t in the cast list so he was or would be written out of the show. However, I hung in there… for last night??? But should I be angry with Common for leaving the show or the show for how he left? It has long been said men can’t walk and chew gum at the same time, I guess Common has just verified that for us. I’m soooo done with “Hell on Wheels.”
wesley thompson
September 14, 2014 @ 2:42 am
Man they producers have just ruined this once great show. Amc fired the creators/executive producers from seaon 1&2. Elam and cullen were the main reason I watched this once great show.man this show just lost one very (ex)loyal fan. Thank you amc & new showrunner tony & troy grayton created a master piece amc and the new producers just ruined this show.
Moose Michaels
September 15, 2014 @ 2:34 pm
As a matter of fact I love the series as a whole but these past two seasons have been the best for me. Lets be grateful we have a western at all on the air!
hans
September 14, 2014 @ 2:17 am
Heartbreaking…