Comments on: ‘The X Factor’ USA notes: Carly Rose Sonenclar, Drew Chadwick, Demi Lovato

By: alex

alex — Fri, 29 Mar 2013 22:30:07 +0000

trevor you’re right, that story was definitely made up. at the parade i wasnt fortunate enough to have a pass to get inside molly spillanes, however i screamed out to carly and she heard me and looked right at me and smiled and waved to me. and obviously i dont know her but im a big fan and she was kind enough to give me that attention and completely make my day, believe me my heart melted! ill be a carly rose fan for life, i love her<3

By: alex

alex — Fri, 29 Mar 2013 22:24:39 +0000

u guys better get used to carly having fans of all ages. her voice and her style are so great that she reaches older people as well even tho she is only about to be 14. also i dont think carly really wants to appeal to only teeny boppers. carly is more mature and has a rich taste in music. she is a true artist. shes not trying to sing cheap pop music that gets played a million times everyday for a month and then disappears. carly has a lot more depth than that, and thats why shes attracting fans of both sexes and all ages

By: Trevor

Trevor — Fri, 22 Mar 2013 20:27:52 +0000

To Angelica….that story you told about your “friend” meeting Carly at her parade is completely fabricated. I know, I was there and I was inside. To be inside to meet her, it was a private party so you had to have a pass, most of the kids were from the Starlight Children’s foundation and then close friends, family, etc. She gave an interview to every single reporter that was allowed access and signed every autograph from every fan who asked for it and did so with a smile on her face. In fact, she ended up staying a little later than expected because some of the people on the guest list were running late and she didn’t want them to miss out on seeing her. I find it interesting how people not only try to tear someone down, but make up stupid little stories to try and accomplish it. Either way, one of you is lying but I guess that makes you feel better about yourself.

By: Oleo

Oleo — Thu, 21 Mar 2013 22:05:27 +0000

Welcome to stardom Carly. Everyone is an expert on what you should wear, how you should act, what you should sing, where you should sing, who you are better than, who you are worse than, who should be your fans, how those fans should act…..well….there seems to be an expert for every part of your existence. Glad none of this matters. I just want to hear you sing….(from one of your older fans…the non creepy kind…)

By: Alycia

Alycia — Tue, 19 Mar 2013 16:15:02 +0000

Angelica- I also met Carly and she was friendly and nice. She posed for pictures. She was awesome. She is human and maybe she was having a bad day or a very long day the day your friend met her. Maybe she didn’t feel good. Who knows give her the benefit of the doubt

By: Alycia

Alycia — Tue, 19 Mar 2013 14:40:12 +0000

Nicole-, you go girl!!! Defend your girls. I respect that. And I’m not bashing them. I wish them well. And I mean all groups break up even the Beatles broke up. Nothing last forever.

By: Rachel

Rachel — Tue, 19 Mar 2013 06:48:30 +0000

Watched the recent singoff between Charley Askey and Aubrey Cleland on IDOL. Aubrey sang OUT HERE ON MY OWN. While it was excellent, it made me realize how special Cece Frey really was … no comparison, Cece killed it.

By: Racine A

Racine A — Tue, 19 Mar 2013 05:00:25 +0000

Is it too much to ask Carly to wear makeup when she goes to see concerts? She looks weird without makeup. Her eyes are way too small for her face. She needs eye makeup. Without it, her nose is too big for her face. The pic I have with her is ruined bc she looked like she just woke up from a hang over.

By: Angelica

Angelica — Tue, 19 Mar 2013 04:44:27 +0000

I watched the x factor. I’m from Hastings, NY. Not far from Carly. So I supported her and Emblem 3. I supported Carly becuz she’s from Westchester county like me. I am 16. I figure she has a great voice and I looked forward to her performances. But my opinion of carly changed forever after one of my friends met her at her parade and one of my twitter followers met her at the Ed Sheeran concert. The friend that met her @ the parade asked Carly inside the restaurant if she can have an autograph and carly said “ugh” and rolled her eyes. She gave attitude. Wasn’t nice. At least she has a pic to prove it..my twitter follower met Carly @ ed’s concert and she saw Carly with her brother and said hi carly. Carly said hi back and carly’s friend scream real loud at this girl. When she asked carly for a picture she ignored this girl. And russ had to be the one to say “maybe later”. I don’t get why Carly is mean in person. I get she does charity but when you meet people in public at least be nice. You are developing a reputation for being mean, stuck up and rude Carly Rose. I hear from people who go to school at Rye Neck how stuck up you are. And what an attitude you give when you meet people.

By: Nicole

Nicole — Tue, 19 Mar 2013 04:27:10 +0000

Alycia, please shut up. I’m on here reading about x factor news and I never say anything but I have had it with you carly rose fans always putting down fifth harmony to make a point. I don’t care if you don’t like them but get your facts straight before you talk sh*t about them. They never asked for money. The 5h fans keep suggesting they get a new camera and all of us fans say we can donate the money if they want. But they don’t need it, they can ask Simon or LA Reid for one. It’s just that they post covers and it could be of better quality if they had a HD camera. They never asked for it. Us fans suggested the new camera. And just because 5H is not out publicizing their philanthropic efforts like Carly doesn’t mean they don’t do it. Lauren volunteers at Catholic charities and Service day. Dinah, Ally, and Normani volunteer with activities involving their church. Sorry if they haven’t do a live event to donate to a cause. They try. Maybe they’ll do one in the future. And yeah girl bands break up but at least they’ll put out an album or two or three. And tour and do concerts. That won’t stop the teen fan base from liking them. Because all 5 are nice girls who don’t trash other people. Most of 5H fans are Carly fans so you aren’t doing Carly any favors by trashing a girl group. Sorry if these other girls come on here to trash carly but not all of us are. And just because some emblem 3 or 5 harmony fans don’t like carly doesn’t mean that all of us do.