Comments on: ‘The X Factor’ USA: Did LeAnn Rimes end up hurting Carly Rose Sonenclar?

By: Really Concerned

Really Concerned — Mon, 24 Dec 2012 01:09:32 +0000

Fox should be ashamed for allowing what went on with the X Factor 2012 show. The Lee Ann Rimes duet was a insult to Carly and her family. Whatever the reason Lee Ann Rimes should have not been allowed to perform. It may or may not have affected the final outcome but, we will never know. What I find alarmimg is the the fact that they didn’t give a breakdown of the 35 million votes to see how close the competition ended. America got it wrong by not voting for the obvious talented person and the deserving winner. I hope it the future when people vote for contestants that they stick to talent and performance and not the smoke and mirrors we had in this competition.

By: Zel

Zel — Sun, 23 Dec 2012 18:44:27 +0000

Shocking that Tate won!! He is a boring has been. Carly Rose is a STAR!! She should have won. Is XFactor also rigged!! Hope not??

By: Her Mom

Her Mom — Sun, 23 Dec 2012 06:34:34 +0000

According to Hollywood Gossip, Carly’s Mom did not blame LeAnn for Carly losing. In my opinion, she is partly to blame, but so is X Factor, Tate, and others.

By: Carly and Tate

Carly and Tate — Sun, 23 Dec 2012 06:32:15 +0000

Carly might have lost her way a little due to the energy of LeAnn coming aboard and all the filth that went along with that and X Factor having no business putting someone with that kind of current reputation on Carly. Boo X Factor games! We’ll see how popular Tate turns out to be in record sales. Simon also threw Carly under the bus with his comments on Carly’s “Imagine.” That song was great; certainly more of a risk with creativity in music making than Tate. And she was perfectly on tone even if it wasn’t normal fare (remember Simon was the only judge who did not like it). Tate is creative at most in his ways of drinking beers with the boys, giving sob stories about how the others didn’t deserve the prize like him, and sticking his nose in crtiqueing and offering derailing comments on other contestants to media in finals. How about all the times in the finals that Tate was flat and off key? Simon never said a word. Boo! Tate was obviously favored despite his mediocre talent compared to a 13-year-old. His talent was generic run of the mill karaoke copying; sure he had a fine voice, but not enough to warrant his win and the horrible sabotaging of Carly by him and others in the final days. Again, LeAnn with her “trainwreck reputation” of late had no business in a duet for the win. Boo again!

By: Carly's Mom

Carly's Mom — Sun, 23 Dec 2012 06:31:21 +0000

Carly’s mom should be livid. Whether she should share it as that could bring bad publicity is another story. Wouldn’t you as a mother or father stick up for your child who was apparently blamed for something by someone in mass media who did not take any accountability of her own? You would be a bad parent if you didn’t. It has nothing to do with “sore loser” and everything to do with being a “hero” against someone pointing destructive fingers at a child when it was clear LeAnn came on stage stumbling before she even met up with Carly. Of course it was LeAnn’s influence (and X Factor’s filthy sabotaging choice to have her in the first place) that derailed Carly who had performed pretty much flawlessly until then, and after then. Hmm. And Simon calling her an alien? That is rude and insensitive. She is just an angel, not a two-bit talentlacking song and dance trick so common in the records now.

By: What a Joke This Simon Bet Is

What a Joke This Simon Bet Is — Sat, 22 Dec 2012 20:15:44 +0000

What a joke the news now says Simon lost a bet to LA that Carly would win. A complete coverup for the fact X Factor is rigged and they threw Carly under the bus with Rimes so she would lose.

By: Of Course

Of Course — Sat, 22 Dec 2012 19:07:00 +0000

Of course she did. Sure didn’t help. X Factor sucks for doing that to Carly Rose.

By: Wow

Wow — Sat, 22 Dec 2012 10:06:53 +0000

Wow, X Factor allowed Carly to be subject to the wolves with this Rimes thing. They must have known that haters would come and divert voting to tweeting about “drunk” LeAnn instead. Stinky move.

By: Funny

Funny — Sat, 22 Dec 2012 09:57:40 +0000

Funny that this whole Rimes fiasco has gone viral in social media, and the fact that Tate won is but a minor point compared. But of course Tate is edging is way in business that is not his again (as he did by trashing Carly backstage on semi-finals–which was judges realm to critique) by saying Rimes had nothing to do with Carly’s loss. Bull! It certainly didn’t help counter loss. Poor Tate once again, all left out and wanting in. Please go take care of your kids who need a father, instead!

By: Best Luck to Rimes

Best Luck to Rimes — Sat, 22 Dec 2012 09:46:46 +0000

May Rimes get the help she needs!