Had to make my own list in comparison:

1) Malcolm Freberg (Philippines) – Seemingly strong competitor with a level head but still has lots to prove. He may pose a bigger threat then what’s actually there (which is his biggest downfall) but it’d be interesting to see him out there on a second run utilizing the skills he picked up on the first time out. Hopefully he learns how to lie better – which at first seemed like a skill he would of had until he blew it by telling Denise about the demise of their alliance.

2) Jim Rice (South Pacific) – Even though he was ousted decently early in his season, I always had a really good feeling about this guy. He always gave it 110% at challenges (eg. the weight lifting record he broke) and he was constantly thinking about strategy. I think if he was given a second chance he could be an absolute wild card in the game. At the very least I’d consider his as a second younger version of the guy we know as Penner.

3) Matt Elrod (Redemption Island) – I’m not a big Matt fan by any means. I don’t think he has what it takes socially in a game that is all about deception and manipulation. But he proved to be a physical beast in the redemption challenges and if anything else it would be interesting to bring back along side Andrea… Just to see if they could actually cooperate on a second time out. He could also be a ‘Hero’ character in this season.

4) Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins) – My number one guy pick to see brought back, but I think it’s highly unlikely that it will ever happen. He had a lot of flaws including having little charm and a bit of a sporadic personality. But he’s very smart, decent in challenges and if he gets himself into a good alliance then he could become extremely deadly. He’s usually considered the brains of the operation. I’d also say that maybe the producers should wait for a Fishbach/Cesternino pairing in a season. That would be gold.

5) Erik Cardona (Samoa) – I’m iffy on putting this name here, being that I don’t know how much people would remember this guy. But Erik was a competitor who fought to be a beast in challenges. He had wild eyes that showed how much he put into everything he did. I’m my opinion he’s a much more interesting version of Brandon Hantz… Just being that he’s clumbsy, not really the smartest and lacked strategically. But he’s not a preacher Christian pre-teen whiner with an attitude problem – which makes him good TV without being annoying.

6) Sabrina Thompson (One World) – She was a part of arguably the strongest female alliance in the history of the game; and she is also level headed and surprisingly great with her words in a final jury tribal. Lots of room for strategic improvement so it would be interesting to see how she progressed on her second trip. I would prefer Kim but I feel like the producers should wait until another full on All-Stars season for her return (if they smarten up and realize that she’s better TV then people give her credit for).

7) Brenda Lowe (Nicaragua) – Probably my least favourite season of the entire series. Yet Brenda was one of two people on it who surprised me with many great social schemes and the ability to lure people into her charm – the other person that season oddly being Sash. Her eviction was a major disappointed when she refused to scramble and just decided to roll over and die. Can’t wait to see her back with hopefully a more aggressive game which would mesh well with that charm that’s just so damn deadly.

8) Andrea Boehike (Redemption Island) – Just like Matt, I’m not the biggest fan of Andrea. But she’s a wildcard in my book. I think she’s smarter then she lets on and she proved that she’s tough enough to knock out three guys at once in a final redemption duel. It’d be interesting to see her in a season when she’s not over shadowed entirely by arguably the most bold and aggressive player to ever play the game. I think she would go deep again in a second season just because she is generally underrated.

9) Taj Johnson (Tocantins) – A more modern version of an earlier Cirie in my opinion – just without all the big epic moves. But I think given a second chance Taj could potentially live up to that type of reputation. She’s smart, has a good judge of character and people trust her. That’s the first step to being a dangerous player in this game. She would also be underrated if brought back (Just like Cirie was in the first Fans vs. Favourites).

10) Corinne Caplan (Gabon) – Corinne scares the hell out of me. She likes being a ‘Villain’ and tearing people apart emotionally. She wants to have that type of edit in this show. And to top it all off, she is good at getting herself into an alliance – and actually having that alliance trust her. I don’t think we have ever seen a female character quite like Corinne on this show, so I really hope she goes deep in a second season if they bring her back. She has the potential to be very rememberable – and possibly even a good player.

How about my choices? Agree or disagree?

Corrine – Gabon
Crystal – Gabon
Ian – Palau
Burton – Pearl Islands
Sierra – Tocantins
Erik – Micronisia
Parvity – Cook Islands
Amy – Guatamala
Marcus – Gabon
Courtney – China

If were going with people that havent played a 2nd time then i would change:

Courtney to Cindy – Guatamala
Parvity to Brett – Samoa