Comments on: ‘Dancing with the Stars’ finale rankings: Should Melissa Rycroft be the winner?

By: rmona

rmona — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 03:20:06 +0000

I think Melissa is a great dancer and she thinks so too! I’m a dancer (not prof.) of course. I had many compliments but I never let it go to my head. I think Melissa is too much of an “I” person and she tries very noticeably to put herself in front of others.
I want to see Shawn and Derek win – they are both great dancers.

By: lydia

lydia — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 01:02:48 +0000

I agree…Kelly should have gotten some 10’s.

By: mames

mames — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 00:59:08 +0000

I believe that it would be wonderful for Melissa and Tony to win the mirror ball trophy…but only if they deserve it based on the merit of their dancing. I can not support their winning just because they have not won before. The trophy has to be earned. That is a very childish reason to give any reward. Kelly and Val may be great dancers but I get turned off by their “chemistry” that should be reserved for another time. My vote goes to Shawn and Derek for their consistent, high-energy, entertaining performances each week. Some have criticized her for her atheletic
status. I, for one, applaud her for her physical endurance, wind power, focus, agility, range of motion and mobilty which enables her to give such outstanding performances. I believe that Shawn and Derek perform for everyone’s enjoyment and do so each week. A by-product is a good review from the judges. A “just as important” item is the overwhelming support of the viewing public. I think that Derek said it perfectly when he stated that long after the show, the scores will be forgotten but the routine will live on in the minds of all who viewed the dance. My first place vote goes for Shawn and Derek. My second place vote goes to Melissa and Tony. Thank you from an Iowa Fan

By: Cecile

Cecile — Sun, 25 Nov 2012 20:56:09 +0000

Shawn and Derek FTW!!!!!! ♥♥♥ I’ll be voting like hell on monday night! ^^

By: Marie

Marie — Sun, 25 Nov 2012 20:53:20 +0000

Let the best dance execution win.To vote for Melissa and Tony just because they have not won the trophy in the past does not justify the honor of winning. At this point, each one Melissa, Shawn and Kelly have shown their prowess and deserve equal chances for the mirrorball trophy.

What I hope to see in the finale are the judges offering non biased, no show of favortisim comments. Call it (technique, skill, creativity) as they see it.

By: Jennifer Brooke Edwards

Jennifer Brooke Edwards — Sun, 25 Nov 2012 14:49:34 +0000

I want melissa and tony to win DWTS ALLSTAR because they have not won on the shows before ?! Melissa and Tony is the FAVORITE people to win the DWTS ALLSTAR and not shawn or kelly because they have won on DWTS before and not Melissa and Tony because they need to win on DWTS ALLSTAR ?! And people out there who like Melissa and Tony to (VOTE,VOTE,VOTE,VOTE) for Melissa and Tony [and not shawn or kelly because they are not the favorite people to win DWTS ALLSTAR] ?! Melissa and Tony are the FAVORITE people to win DWTS ALLSTAR !!!! (Please Please VOTE,VOTE ,VOTE,VOTE,VOTE for Melissa and Tony to win DWTS ALLSTAR)!!!!

By: rosie r fidler

rosie r fidler — Sun, 25 Nov 2012 07:11:52 +0000

Kelly Monaco never received a 10 from the Judges. It’s very obvious, she’s not the favorite of them. She should have gotten couple of 10’s already.