Comments on: ‘The X Factor’ USA review: Beatrice Miller, CeCe Frey, and a massive rant

By: tracy

tracy — Fri, 30 Nov 2012 19:42:53 +0000

i ment to say ceecee personity is rude not very nice i hope she kick off next week if she dont it fix

By: tracy

tracy — Fri, 30 Nov 2012 19:40:32 +0000

ceecee is not a good singer and her personity is just very nice i think she should of got kick off the frist week when they started voteing off ceecee should of been vote off the frist week

By: Angela

Angela — Tue, 27 Nov 2012 15:47:32 +0000

CeeCee suck! That’s the bottom line! She is not unique! She is fake.

By: CarlyRoseFan

CarlyRoseFan — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 16:44:07 +0000

. . .the judge’s are good. The show is a good as any other show promoting songs. If it weren’t so, they wouldn’t have such a high rating. Geez…PLEASE STOP IT WITH THIS BEATRICE! That little girl can not sing! Her voice was hoarse, shaky, and she NEVER hit a single high note the entire time she was there. Just because she’s cute doesn’t mean she can sing!! I did not care about her tears AT ALL. I’m sorry. I had to drop a tear every since she made it to the final show over people that were so much better.

By: CarlyRoseFan

CarlyRoseFan — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 16:39:02 +0000

Give me a break!! I was very irritated watching Beatrice’s terrible performance week after week. She belongs on a Disney show, not on stage. I don’t believe they should had allowed her to got that far. She does not have a $5mill voice at all, neither does CeCe, but she can definitely hit a note that Beatrice never did attempt. As far as age, the limit is fine. Carly Rose is perfect. I love every performance, and it gets better every week. I will be the first in line to buy this girls album!

By: Eric

Eric — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 15:32:33 +0000

“So why the change? It’s simple: Carly had the final spot on last night’s show, while Tate was forced to perform in the less-than-lucrative lead-off spot.”

Sorry but your wrong!!

Explain why Carly’s last performance has 3 million views on youtube, while Tate’s is around 400,000? Because Carly went last ……?

By: Brad

Brad — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 00:17:21 +0000

The whole CeCe sister thing is just one example of oozing insincerity! The sister (may she RIP) died the same year CeCe was born. So how could such a bond have been formed. It was total garbage. Shame on CeCe for using a dead sister to make herself look more human. And shame on her parens for going along with it!

By: Brad

Brad — Mon, 26 Nov 2012 00:13:03 +0000

For some reason the US version of the X Factor just doesn’t work – maybe it doesn’t sit well in American culture. If you have a chance to watch the UK or the Australian version, you would swear it is a completely different show. I agree with the age limit thing- most 13 year olds can come across as mature, until things start going downhill. It was painful to watch last week, and by the by, Beatrice outsang that LIttle MIss Insincerity CeCe, and didn’t really deserve to go.

Obviously the judges, apart from LA and Simon are practically useless, and at least 50 percent of the hosting is bad (although improving), but somehow that is bot it. I think it has something to do with the over the top back stories all of the contestants seem to have. The audience is not dumb enough to believe most of them. Let’s face it, not one of them says they had a happy pre-X Factor Life. It was all tragedy and heartbreat, diseased and living in abject poverty with no one to love them or only one parent. Give me a break, none of them are that good at acting to sell such crap!

By: RGS

RGS — Sun, 25 Nov 2012 14:46:21 +0000

I think Beatrice was fantastic, her voice is hauntingly beautiful and she has great talent, she has a beautiful face can dance and does dress like a 13 year old. I like that because she is not trying to be 21. I think Simon had no right to vote on her age factor. He is supposed to have voted on her talent. Simon stop pushing your own wagon and judge the talent. The three 13 year olds had the best voices. Beatrice certainly was badly mentored. She was overwhelmed seeing her sisters and had never had to sing off before. Every performance has been incredible, all the contestants were emotional and I think it was stupid time to have that theme a night before eliminations. I have seen many contestants cry and sob and they have been a lot older than Beatrice. The judges have to take some responsibility, they have told Beatrice how good she was each week and nobody can tell me she was prepared for the playoff and how to deal with. Stop blaming the age limit and lets ask questions about the mentoring on this show. Good luck Beatrice you are brilliant. you are one of a kind. keep going do not give up

By: nerdychick83

nerdychick83 — Sat, 24 Nov 2012 23:03:53 +0000

The age limit should stay. If Paige and Cece are allowed to cry (fake or real) tears on a daily basis than the kids should be allowed to as well. Why do we like watch reality shows if america cannot deal with the reality of somebody crying? I would be happy with anybody but Cece winning.